MORMON MISSIONARY:
We absolutely consider ourselves Christian. The official name of our church is The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Jesus Christ is central to everything we believe. We pray in His name. We worship Him as Savior. We believe He is the Son of God, that He atoned for our sins, died, rose again, & makes salvation possible. We read the Bible. We preach repentance, baptism, faith, discipleship, moral living, family, & eternal life through Christ. So when people say we are not Christian, it feels like they are ignoring what we actually confess.
CAGE STAGE CALVINIST:
I hear the claim. But using the name “Jesus” is not enough. Muslims believe in Jesus. Jehovah’s Witnesses believe in Jesus. Arians believed in Jesus. Ancient heretics quoted Scripture while gutting the Gospel like a fish on a dock. The question is not, “Do you use Christian vocabulary?” The question is, “Do you confess the Christ of biblical & historic Christianity?”
MORMON MISSIONARY:
But that assumes historic Creeds are the standard. We believe the Bible is the Word of God as far as it is translated correctly. We also believe God restored lost truths through Joseph Smith. The Creeds came after the Apostles, during a time of confusion & philosophical corruption. We do not accept that Councils of men have the right to define Christianity against modern revelation. We believe God still speaks.
CAGE STAGE CALVINIST:
And there is the issue. Christianity, historically, has never been an undefined religious fog bank where anyone who says “Jesus” gets a membership card. The Creeds are not random decorative plaques. The Apostles’ Creed, Nicene Creed, Athanasian Creed, & Chalcedonian Definition are boundary markers. They define the triune God, the person of Christ, the Incarnation, & the faith once delivered.
When Mormonism explicitly rejects the historic Creeds as corrupt — and in Joseph Smith’s First Vision account, the existing Christian Creeds are called an “abomination” — Mormonism is not merely disagreeing with one denomination. It is rejecting the historic doctrinal grammar of Christianity itself.
MORMON MISSIONARY:
But Protestants also reject parts of tradition. The Reformers rejected Roman Catholic Councils, papal authority, & many inherited practices. Why can Protestants reject tradition & still be Christian, but Latter-day Saints cannot reject Creeds & claim restoration?
CAGE STAGE CALVINIST:
Because the Reformation rejected corrupt additions while affirming catholic orthodoxy. Luther, Calvin, Cranmer, the Reformed confessions, the Lutheran confessions — all affirmed the Trinity, the Incarnation, the deity of Christ, the one eternal God, creation from nothing, & the orthodox Christology guarded by the early Creeds.
The Reformers did not say, “The Nicene doctrine of God is an abomination.” They said Rome had corrupted the Gospel with false doctrines like papal supremacy, Purgatory, indulgences, & a defective view of justification. That is a surgical correction. Mormonism is not surgery. It is a different anatomy.
MORMON MISSIONARY:
We believe in the Father, Son, & Holy Ghost. We believe they are united in purpose & glory. We believe Jesus is divine. We believe He is the Savior. Why is your philosophical language about “one essence” & “3 persons” necessary? Isn’t that Greek metaphysics imposed on the Bible?
CAGE STAGE CALVINIST:
No. That is the old anti-creedal dodge. “Greek metaphysics” is the scarecrow people build when they want biblical doctrine without precise boundaries.
The Church used careful language because heretics abused biblical language. Arius could say Jesus was “Son of God.” Sabellius could say Father, Son, & Spirit. Nestorius could honour Christ. The question was always: what do you mean?
Historic Christianity confesses one God, eternally existing in 3 persons: Father, Son, & Holy Spirit. Not 3 gods united in purpose. Not one exalted being among a species of gods. Not God as once a man who progressed. Not human beings becoming gods of the same kind. The God of Scripture is eternal, uncreated, immutable, sovereign, & alone God. “Before Me no god was formed, nor shall there be any after Me.” That kills Mormon theology with a thunderclap.
MORMON MISSIONARY:
We would say you misunderstand us. We do not worship many gods in the sense of pagan chaos. We worship Heavenly Father in the name of Jesus Christ. We believe God’s plan is about exaltation, family, covenant, obedience, & becoming like Him through grace. Early Christians spoke of theosis — becoming partakers of the divine nature. So our view is not as alien as critics claim.
CAGE STAGE CALVINIST:
Theosis in orthodox Christianity means participation in divine life by grace, union with Christ, transformation into holiness — not becoming gods by nature, not progressing into deity, not a cosmos populated by exalted beings of the same species as God. You are taking orthodox words & loading them with different metaphysics.
That is the central problem. Mormonism keeps Christian terms but redefines the dictionary. God, Christ, grace, salvation, Heaven, priesthood, exaltation, Atonement — same labels, different contents. It is like putting “milk” on a bottle of paint & then acting shocked when Christians refuse to pour it on cereal.
MORMON MISSIONARY:
But surely the basic mark of being Christian is faith in Jesus Christ & striving to follow Him.
CAGE STAGE CALVINIST:
No. That is too thin. Christianity is not merely admiration for Jesus plus moral effort. Christianity is defined by the apostolic Gospel: the eternal Son, consubstantial with the Father, became man, lived under the Law, died as a penal substitute for sinners, rose bodily, ascended, & saves by grace alone through faith alone, apart from works, to the glory of God alone.
If your “Jesus” is the spirit-brother of humanity, the offspring of Heavenly Parents, not the eternally begotten Son sharing the one divine essence with the Father, then you are not confessing the Christian Christ. You are using Christian names for a different being.
MORMON MISSIONARY:
That sounds exclusionary.
CAGE STAGE CALVINIST:
Definitions exclude. That is what definitions do. If “Christian” means anything that mentions Jesus positively, the word becomes useless theological soup. The Creeds are not optional historical wallpaper. They mark the difference between Christianity & counterfeit Christianity.
Mormonism explicitly claims the historic Church fell into apostasy, the Creeds are corrupt, priesthood authority was lost, & Joseph Smith restored the true Church. Fine. But then be honest: that means Mormonism does not see itself as historic Nicene Christianity. It sees itself as a restoration replacing historic Christianity.
MORMON MISSIONARY:
We see ourselves as the restored fullness of Christianity.
CAGE STAGE CALVINIST:
Exactly. And historic Christianity sees that as a confession that you are outside Christianity’s doctrinal boundaries. You cannot reject the creedal definition of God & Christ, call those Creeds abominable, replace the Church’s doctrine with restorationist revelation, & then demand to be counted inside the very faith you say had fundamentally apostatized.
That is not bigotry. That is basic category sanity.
MORMON MISSIONARY:
So you would say Latter-day Saints are sincere but not Christian?
CAGE STAGE CALVINIST:
Many are sincere. Many are moral. Many are family-loving, disciplined, kind, zealous, & serious. But sincerity does not make false doctrine true. Mormonism is not Christian in the historic, creedal, biblical sense. It is a restorationist religion that uses Christian language while rejecting the doctrinal heart of Christianity: the triune God, the eternal Son, & the once-for-all Gospel of grace.
The issue is not whether Mormons are nice people. The issue is whether Mormonism confesses the God & Christ confessed by the Apostles & guarded by the Creeds.
It does not.
And if the Creeds are definitional to Christianity, then a movement that calls those Creeds abominations has, by its own mouth, stepped outside the Christian house while still trying to keep the nameplate on the door.
Credits: A friend sent me the text without documentation. Sorry for that. Dennis
0 Comments:
Post a Comment